FOS decisions / Pension Administration
Pension Administration
Financial Ombudsman Service final decisions, reproduced verbatim from the FOS published decisions register.
Decisions
83
Upheld
47
Not upheld
36
Avg redress
£741
Upheld complaints (47)
Aviva Life & Pensions UK Limited
DRN-6226111A pension provider must handle benefit claims promptly and accurately, and must provide fair compensation for errors, delays, and resulting distress.
UpheldFeb 2026The Prudential Assurance Company Limited
DRN-6101988A financial services provider must provide timely and adequate information to customers and handle service failures with appropriate remedial action.
UpheldRedress £200Dec 2025Quilter Financial Services Limited
DRN-6084974A financial services provider must act on client instructions promptly and accurately, and compensation should put the client in the position they would have been in but for the error.
UpheldDec 2025Phoenix Life Limited
DRN-5962644Complaints must be referred to the Financial Ombudsman Service within six months of the respondent's final response letter, and the ombudsman lacks jurisdiction to consider complaints made outside this time limit unless exceptional circumst
UpheldRedress £350Nov 2025Scottish Widows Limited
DRN-6079099A pension provider must pay annuity payments on time and apply agreed indexation increases, and must handle complaints promptly and competently.
UpheldRedress £966ReAssure Limited
DRN-5863186Compensation for negligent misstatement of pension benefits should restore the consumer to the position they would have been in if the error had not occurred, not purchase the incorrectly stated benefits.
UpheldScottish Widows Limited
DRN-5585252A firm must communicate information to customers in a way which is clear, fair and not misleading, and must pay due regard to the information needs of its clients, particularly where changes to terms and conditions have a material impact.
UpheldLegal & General (Portfolio Management Services) Ltd
DRN-5719205Pension trustees must exercise their discretion reasonably and fairly when determining death benefit distributions to dependants, and must provide adequate explanation for discretionary awards.
UpheldRedress £500ReAssure Limited
DRN-5877357A provider must comply with HMRC trivial commutation rules which prevent lump sum payments when total pension value exceeds £30,000, but must clearly explain these restrictions and the available options to the consumer.
UpheldRedress £300Scottish Equitable Plc trading as Aegon
DRN-5937505A pension provider must provide reasonable access to account information and ensure contributions are properly applied, though compensation is limited to demonstrable losses or trouble and upset rather than directing business operations.
UpheldRedress £400ReAssure Limited
DRN-5616448A pension administrator must promptly process contributions, maintain accurate records, and provide clear confirmation of transactions to the scheme member.
UpheldRedress £500Phoenix Life Limited
DRN-5953202A pension provider must obtain explicit consent before removing a consumer from a chosen lifestyling strategy and switching them to a different fund with different risk characteristics.
UpheldThe Prudential Assurance Company Limited
DRN-6107423A pension provider must provide adequate information and documentation to beneficiaries in a timely manner, and must not misrepresent its record-keeping practices.
UpheldRedress £300Hargreaves Lansdown Asset Management Limited
DRN-5958128A pension provider must not make payments from a customer's account without clear, explicit instruction from the customer, even if documentation from a third party could be reasonably interpreted as supporting such action.
UpheldAviva Life & Pensions UK Limited
DRN-6047126A pension provider must not provide conflicting information about transfer eligibility and must apply consistent, accurate calculations regarding Guaranteed Minimum Pension costs.
UpheldRedress £215ReAssure Limited
DRN-6152644A pension administrator must maintain accurate address records, process pension benefits via the consumer's stated payment method, and respond promptly to complaints with appropriate management escalation.
UpheldRedress £300The Royal London Mutual Insurance Society Limited
DRN-6131528A pension provider must give clear information about its pricing methodology when processing fund switches, particularly when the consumer specifically inquires about pricing timing.
UpheldRedress £250Zurich Assurance Ltd
DRN-6138421A pension provider must make reasonable attempts to locate a policyholder to pay accrued benefits, particularly after the policyholder reaches retirement age and receives correspondence marked undelivered.
UpheldRedress £14,110Mattioli Woods Limited
DRN-5950068A SIPP provider must conduct adequate due diligence on financial advisers who introduce business, including verification of their credentials and regulatory status.
UpheldScottish Widows Limited
DRN-6180236A pension provider must accurately calculate pension valuations, particularly where a policy has been partially settled, and cannot rely on incorrect higher valuations provided due to systemic errors.
UpheldRedress £300Phoenix Life Limited
DRN-5690111A financial services provider must provide accurate valuations to consumers making important decisions about their policies, and bears responsibility when errors prevent consumers from making informed choices.
UpheldRixon Matthews Appleyard (Financial Services) Limited
DRN-5991608A financial services firm is vicariously liable for unsuitable investment advice given by its authorised representative, even if the firm denies the client relationship and has no records of the advice.
UpheldIFG Pensions Limited
DRN-6021764A financial services firm must handle customer requests and complaints with due care and without unnecessary delay, and must provide adequate redress for losses caused by its own delays.
UpheldRedress £300Phoenix Life Limited
DRN-6029510A life insurance provider must provide clear, fair and not misleading information about policy performance, fund value and charges within a reasonable timeframe when costs exceed premiums.
UpheldRedress £300Countrywide Assured Plc
DRN-5937508A provider must respond to information requests and complaints within reasonable timeframes and provide accurate information necessary for customers to make informed financial decisions.
UpheldRedress £400Suffolk Life Pensions Limited
DRN-6266547A pension provider must balance the rights of a deceased member's beneficiary to inherit assets against the contractual rights of other syndicate members under a group investment agreement.
UpheldLondon & Colonial Services Limited
DRN-5635926A SIPP operator must ensure that investments held within the pension are appropriate and must not allow unsuitable investments to be made without proper due diligence.
UpheldZurich Assurance Ltd
DRN-6154522A pension provider must notify the transferring firm of material changes in transfer value before completion to allow the consumer to make an informed decision.
UpheldScottish Equitable Plc trading as Aegon
DRN-6053989A pension provider must correctly record and apply customer contributions promptly and keep customers informed of the status of their accounts.
UpheldRedress £300Scottish Widows Limited
DRN-5813349A pension provider must process transfer instructions received within the statutory grace period before automatically annuitizing a member's stakeholder pension at the normal retirement date.
UpheldHBOS Investment Fund Managers Limited
DRN-6194430A pension provider must act promptly on transfer requests and cannot impose requirements (such as evidence of financial advice) that are not actually necessary to process the transfer.
UpheldRedress £772Aviva Life & Pensions UK Limited
DRN-6200979A pension provider should use the fund value as at the date it receives a completed application form, not an earlier quotation date, when processing pension benefit payments.
UpheldLegal and General Assurance Society Limited
DRN-6065333Pension contributions arising from National Insurance rebates for contracting out of SERPS are protected rights and must benefit from annual increases.
UpheldPhoenix Life Limited
DRN-6219255With-profits pension providers must manage funds in accordance with their Principles and Practices of Financial Management document and are entitled to exercise wide discretion in fund management and benefit calculation, provided they opera
UpheldRedress £150Phoenix Life Limited
DRN-6172880Compensation for distress and inconvenience should reflect the overall impact of a business's mistakes, rather than being calculated by reference to the complainant's professional hourly rate.
UpheldRedress £350Phoenix Life Limited trading as Standard Life
DRN-5643361A pension provider must not provide conflicting information about transfer options that leads to consumer detriment, and consumers have a duty to mitigate losses when provided with clear information that a transfer cannot proceed.
UpheldRedress £250Wesleyan Assurance Society
DRN-6144916A provider must notify a customer of significant account changes before implementation and clearly explain the reasons, giving the customer an opportunity to object.
UpheldRothesay Life Plc
DRN-6014606Pension annuity payments must commence on the next four-weekly pay period following retirement as per the buy-out agreement terms, not on the member's chosen retirement date.
UpheldRedress £250Hargreaves Lansdown Advisory Services Limited
DRN-6026160A discretionary portfolio manager is not in breach of duty merely because fund performance lags alternatives or charges could be lower, provided the portfolio is managed consistently with the agreed risk profile and mandate.
UpheldScottish Equitable Plc trading as Aegon
DRN-6247225A firm must respond to customer queries within its service standards to avoid causing avoidable delays and financial loss.
UpheldAviva Life & Pensions UK Limited
DRN-6233850A pension provider must handle pension transfer processes with reasonable care and clarity, particularly regarding what assets can be transferred and the timing of communications about transfer feasibility.
UpheldRedress £250ReAssure Limited
DRN-5515274A pension provider must provide accurate plan values to customers and should compensate for financial loss and distress caused by providing incorrect information that induces reliance on false figures.
UpheldRedress £1,250Phoenix Life Limited
DRN-6230800An insurance provider must clearly disclose the reviewable nature of a whole of life policy and ensure the policyholder understands that premiums may need to increase or benefits reduce at review points.
UpheldScottish Equitable Plc
DRN-5744615Pension providers must provide customers with sufficient information about investment strategies and funds to enable informed decision-making, even when the employer selected the default fund.
UpheldRedress £300Evelyn Partners Investment Management Services Limited
DRN-6168820A pension administrator must accurately inform other parties of the current status of a client's pension arrangements to ensure compensation is paid to the correct provider without unnecessary delay.
UpheldOptions UK Personal Pensions LLP
DRN-6125577A SIPP provider must conduct adequate due diligence before accepting introductions from unregulated firms and must properly assess the suitability of investments for holding within a SIPP.
UpheldAscot Lloyd Limited
DRN-6023772A financial adviser must conduct the annual reviews that a consumer is paying for under an ongoing advice arrangement, and cannot retain charges when reviews are not performed.
UpheldRedress £400
Not-upheld complaints (36)
Aviva Life & Pensions UK Limited
DRN-6227282A pension provider is not obliged to warn members of fund value decreases or risk rating changes, and members are responsible for reviewing their investments regularly in accordance with their chosen investment strategy.
Not upheldMar 2026Scottish Widows Limited
DRN-6177891Compensation for customer service failures should be assessed on their own merits based on actual impact, not inflation-adjusted historical comparisons.
Not upheldFeb 2026Aviva Life & Pensions UK Limited
DRN-6182772An insurer's failure to conduct required policy reviews does not necessarily mean a consumer would have made different decisions had they been properly informed, particularly when those decisions would have required substantial premium incr
Not upheldFeb 2026Phoenix Life Limited
DRN-6175106A pension plan's suitability for contracting out of SERPS at the time of sale cannot be reassessed based on subsequent poor investment performance, particularly where the original advice was already reviewed and compensation paid under the
Not upheldOct 2025Financial Administration Services Limited
DRN-6154327A pension provider administering a plan is not required to provide financial advice or independently verify instructions from professional advisers, particularly regarding complex tax exemptions that fall outside the provider's role.
Not upheldAJ Bell Management Limited
DRN-6211911A pension administrator is not liable for unclear information about tax treatment when correct information was available in the plan's terms and conditions, and the consumer had not relied solely on that misinformation in making their decis
Not upheldPhoenix Life Limited
DRN-6194351A pension provider cannot be held liable for paying a pension it cannot locate in its systems, despite historical administration, where the scheme was wound up and records may have been legitimately deleted under GDPR.
Not upheldWealth At Work Limited
DRN-6171239A pension provider is not obliged to accept contributions from deferred members and is free to set its own terms for products offered.
Not upheldSt. James's Place Wealth Management Plc
DRN-6253184An Early Withdrawal Charge is fair if the consumer was clearly informed of its terms and rates at the time the contributions were made.
Not upheldSt. James's Place Wealth Management Plc
DRN-6253190An Early Withdrawal Charge that recovers previously earned but not yet received advice fees is not an 'early exit charge' prohibited by COBS 19.6A and may be fairly applied if clearly disclosed.
Not upheldScottish Widows Limited
DRN-6177900A pension provider is not liable for financial loss where a consumer fails to take advantage of optional features they were made aware of in standard retirement documentation, even if reminder communications were inadequate.
Not upheldPhoenix Life Limited trading as Standard Life
DRN-6246434A pension provider must not provide misleading information about available retirement benefit options, even if statements contain generic illustrations, when it knows the customer is non-resident and those options are unavailable to them.
Not upheldAJ Bell Management Limited
DRN-6246527A pension commencement lump sum cannot be cancelled or returned once paid, except in cases of genuine administrative error, and providing incorrect information about cancellation rights does not entitle a consumer to reverse a withdrawal th
Not upheldPhoenix Life Limited
DRN-6090671A consumer must refer a complaint to the Financial Ombudsman Service within six months of the firm's final response letter, and failure to do so bars consideration unless exceptional circumstances apply.
Not upheldRothesay Life Plc
DRN-6220838Financial services providers are not obligated to provide online portal access as it is an additional service rather than a core regulatory requirement.
Not upheldScottish Widows Limited
DRN-6249397A pension provider is not required to offer flexibility to take benefits as a lump sum once a policyholder reaches age 75, provided adequate notice of the default annuity purchase was given beforehand.
Not upheldPhoenix Life Limited trading as Standard Life
DRN-5967323A pension provider has no obligation to hold or provide historical charges in monetary terms prior to when regulatory requirements mandated such reporting.
Not upheldThe Royal London Mutual Insurance Society Limited
DRN-6023671A pension plan member's request to change the default fund investment is only valid once the plan account is live and established on the provider's system.
Not upheldAviva Life & Pensions UK Limited
DRN-6254085Insurers must provide clear, fair and not misleading information about reviewable policies, particularly regarding fund performance, charges and sustainability, within 12 months of costs exceeding premiums.
Not upheldPhoenix Life Limited
DRN-6255084With-profits pension providers have wide discretion in fund management subject to their PPFM and FCA oversight, and cash equivalent values are calculated using notional conversion factors based on interest rates, annuity rates, and life exp
Not upheldPhoenix Life trading as Standard Life
DRN-5363429A firm acts fairly and reasonably when it applies consistent policy decisions on a case-by-case basis and asks regulatory-compliant questions during pension withdrawal requests.
Not upheldRoyal London Mutual Insurance Society, Limited
DRN-6264772A non-advised annuity sale with clear documentation of non-advised status and explicit warnings about lack of suitability assessment does not constitute a breach of regulatory obligations where the consumer made an informed choice.
Not upheldInteractive Investor Services Limited
DRN-6129167A pension provider is not responsible for losses arising from sanctions on investments or HMRC pension transfer rules that are outside the provider's control.
Not upheldJust Financial Planning Ltd
DRN-6217480A financial adviser is not responsible for delays or issues arising from third-party pension providers or fund managers acting outside their control.
Not upheldPhoenix Life Limited
DRN-6115369A with-profits pension fund's declining value due to market conditions and policy mechanics does not constitute a breach of regulatory or contractual obligations by the provider.
Not upheldAviva Life & Pensions UK Limited
DRN-6196958A pension provider must clearly communicate ill health retirement criteria to medical practitioners, but conflicting information that is subsequently corrected does not necessarily prevent a claim from progressing if the GP can still make a
Not upheldScottish Equitable Plc
DRN-6184776A pension provider does not act unfairly or unreasonably by completing pension transfers within industry-standard timescales, even if separate wrappers are processed at different times.
Not upheldLegal & General (Portfolio Management Services) Ltd
DRN-6069614A pension provider is not in breach if it invests regular contributions in the default fund as set out in plan documentation, even if the transferred funds were invested differently per the consumer's instructions.
Not upheldThe Prudential Assurance Company Limited
DRN-5884082An annuity provider is not obliged to allow changes to fundamental policy terms after the initial cancellation period has expired, particularly where the policy documentation clearly states this at the outset.
Not upheldAviva Life & Pensions UK Limited
DRN-6236178An annuity can only commence once the completed annuity payment form has been returned to the provider; a planned retirement date does not automatically trigger annuity commencement without the necessary documentation being completed and su
Not upheldLegal and General Assurance Society Limited
DRN-6105064An insurer may adjust annuity income if medical information subsequently obtained from a doctor differs materially from information provided on the application form, where the applicant failed to answer with reasonable care.
Not upheldPensionBee Limited
DRN-6096860Pension trustees have discretion over death benefit distribution and cannot disclose third-party beneficiary information due to GDPR data protection obligations.
Not upheldScottish Widows Limited
DRN-6133556A pension provider is not required to provide financial advice about fund switching options, and system or process inconveniences do not constitute unreasonable barriers if multiple channels for switching are available.
Not upheldWesleyan Assurance Society
DRN-6238033A pension provider is entitled to set its own policy requiring financial advice before entering into drawdown arrangements, provided it is applied consistently.
Not upheldPension Insurance Corporation plc
DRN-5825748A DC pension scheme with an RST underpin guarantee is fundamentally a defined contribution arrangement, not defined benefit, and a bulk annuity buyout securing the underpin does not transform the underlying classification of the member's be
Not upheldPhoenix Life Limited
DRN-6167559A pension provider's explanation of notional disinvestment and rounding in income payments must be accurate and tailored to the consumer's specific circumstances.
Not upheld